There’s a section of Yellowstone National Park where you could probably get away with murder. The ‘Zone of Death’ is a 50- square-mile area on the Idaho side of the park that’s entirely uninhabited. If you committed a crime within the zone, there could be no jury because nobody lives there, a trial would be impossible, and, therefore, you could not be convicted. Source Source 2 Source 3
do you have to be tried within 50 miles of your crime or
No, the issue is that the entirety of Yellowstone was assigned to Wyoming’s legal jurisdiction but this segment of the park is in Idaho. If you committed a federal crime there you’d be entitled to trial by a jury of your peers from the state where the crime was committed, which would have to be people who live in Idaho while also living under Wyoming’s governance. There is no one in the world who fits that category. Hence, no jury, no trial.
That’s not true. Deaths in state parks can be adjudicated on the Federal level. State Troopers would investigate and would refer to the state bureau of investigations.
You want to tell that to the constitutional lawyer who wrote the article about it and then tried to get Congress to fix it?
I’m telling you…that’s complete obfuscation. They would simply do as they always do, and transfer jurisdiction for the case, moving the trial to another county. Where a jury would be selected. It’s happened thousands of times. There is actually no place in the US except for embassies or reservations where you aren’t subject to US law, and even the latter has some caveats.
This is something I’m actually knowledgeable on.
And yes, the discussion of this is pointless if there’s no witnesses and you have fifty miles to bury the body. You’d get away with it anyway.